Alternate Count

On icharts forum,I posted my Counts in following manner:

And in response I got an alternate count from P_Wangdu as follows:

I have posted following two observations in response to these labels:
I feel the (ii) of C --5136-5378--is an Impulse and should not be counted as Corrective (ii)
And if I attempt to complete this Corrective (ii) by taking it as a=5136-5378;b=5378-5184;c=5184-5342(truncated c as it failed to go above a)-----then (iii)=5342-4789 no longer remains extended vis-a-vis (i) 

I am posting these here to ellicit response from other participants.
And I wish to specifically mention that all Probabilities must be kept in mind and one must play each wave as it comes. As a clear uptrend has yet to estabish itself, far-fetched shots should be avoided

Raghu